This episode takes us into the day in the life of Robert “Mac” McCready (aka Creepy McCready). It confirms that without a doubt he is a sexual predator. On the day that he is set to be Memphis Man of the Year, he must juggle a variety of tasks for the Greenleaf family both professionally and personally. He is distracted by his obsession with his teenage neighbor, Makayla, and mounting paranoia stemming from the fact that Grace has returned and is currently investigating him. The McCready patriarch, Henry McCready (aka Seedy McCready), pays unwelcome visits to extort money from Robert triggering the pain and guilt of his mother’s death.
As a result, things begin to unravel and spiral out of control. Robert makes a critical error leading auditors to focus on Bishop Greenleaf’s personal income. The threat of this investigation causes Bishop Greenleaf to rebuke Robert giving him 24 hours to resolve before informing Lady Mae. Suspecting that Grace influenced auditors he confronts Grace demanding to know what she had done threaten her to stay out of his way. Once learning that Grace was responding to an inquiry from the auditor for a personal matter, Robert realizes he has made another critical error revealing that he does have something to hide.
When Robert refuses to advocate for Jacob and promote Jacob’s business plan to get Bishop Greenleaf back on television, Jacob offends him by reminding him how Bishop Greenleaf forgive him in lieu of Faith’s sexual molestation allegation. Jacob would apologize later.
Robert warns Charity against hiring Carlton C. Cruise, who has sued his last two employers for wrongful termination. He recommends that he is hired as an independent contractor, but Charity champions for Carlton to be hired as a W2 employee entitling him to benefits.
Pastor Thomas Sneed solicits Robert’s help in obtaining tickets for the Man of Year event. Robert directs him to see his secretary.
Robert goes to Noah’s office to have Noah address the breach of security protocols. When he approaches Noah’s office he overhears Isabel and Noah arguing about an $800 cake for their wedding. Robert informs Noah that Seedy got in and asked Noah to ensure his staff was updated. Robert attempts to set the record straight with Noah believing that Grace has told him about the bad blood between them. Noah denies any knowledge of what Robert is talking about. Later, Robert contacts Isabel offering to purchase the cake of her choice as a wedding gift.
Robert encounters Zora and Sophia waiting for Pastor Ramona so they could assist with a food drive. The girls both ask theological questions about whether Jesus actual died then rose from the dead and the existence of Hell. His interaction with Zora and Sophia makes Sophia view Robert in a more positive light.
His submission to their father’s extortion infuriates Lady Mae. We are left to wonder if Robert has lost his allies.Throughout his day, he is fixated on a picture in a classic portraits book. His fixation with the picture shows us that he has a type. The picture is of a woman that resembles both Makayla and Sophia. We learn how he operates and gains the trust of an unsuspecting Makayla . Makayla is a troubled teen with a parent that struggles with mental illness and alcohol abuse. She is often alone and apparently suicidal. This episode starts with a dream sequence of Robert and Makayla in the bed together and ends with Robert luring Makayla into his condo.